19 min read

SBA 213: Creating your own Pandemic Mode Part 1

By Phil Zito on Aug 3, 2020 6:00:00 AM

Topics: Podcasts

In this episode, we discuss what a Pandemic Mode is, how Pandemic modes work, how to inventory your building systems and changes you can make to your sequence of operations.

Click here to download or listen to this episode now.

Resources mentioned in this episode


 


 
Subscribe via iTunes


 Subscribe via Stitcher

Transcript

Phil Zito 0:00
This is the smart buildings Academy podcast with Phil Zito Episode 213. Hey folks, Phil Zito here and welcome to Episode 213 of the smart buildings Academy podcast. And in this episode we are going to be talking about creating your own pandemic mode. We're going to go through what a pandemic mode is we're going to talk about the general purpose of it. We're going to talk about how you implement the pandemic mode in your control system. We're also going to dive through some of the resources that are available on the ASHRAE website. They have a really good Coronavirus website page that goes through a lot of really good details. So we're going to be talking through that as well. So with that being said, all resources that are mentioned in this episode can be found at podcasts. dot smart buildings Academy.

Phil Zito 1:00
dot com forward slash 213 once again that is podcasts dot smart buildings academy.com forward slash episode or four slash 213. And I want to be clear that is podcasts, not podcasts. So podcasts not smart buildings academy.com for slash to 13. All right, so let's dive in. So what is pandemic mode? You know, when you are thinking about re occupying a building, depending on what kind of surveys you're reading anywhere from 60 to 30%, or 30 to 60% of people say that the condition of the building is directly impacting their decision of whether they want to reoccupy a building or not. And although I haven't seen this happening yet, I'm sure there is litigation

Phil Zito 2:00
Coming in the form of liability for people who supposedly got sick due to the conditions within a building? I haven't seen it. I haven't read about it in the news, you think it would be all over the news if it was happening, but I would not be surprised to see class action lawsuits of some sort saying, hey, did this cause this, I would not be surprised. So one way you can potentially work around these issues is by implementing a pandemic mode. Now, I do want to caution before we go any further, I'm not a lawyer. This is not legal advice. I am just someone who is providing their interpretation of the recommendations that are available on the ASHRAE site based on my own personal experience. Please go and consult a professional before implementing any of these strategies. With that being said, let's dive in. So what is this pandemic mode? What is this general purpose

Phil Zito 3:00
purpose will pandemic mode is basically a mode that says, hey, let's go through the building let's flush out the building. It could be anything from flushing the building with fresh air to simply going in increasing air changes to changing filtering to monitoring the problem with pandemic mode. While it's very sexy from a marketing perspective, the actual definition of pandemic mode varies based on who you're talking to. If you're talking to some organizations, they will simply tell you that it is more monitoring and more control which coincidentally ties to your need to upgrade a building automation system which they will happily provide you so you can kind of see the marketing in that aspect. And then on the flip side, you have what in my opinion is best in class which is the general recommendation

Phil Zito 4:00
By ASHRAE, around what they determine pandemic mode be and essentially from their definition, it's more outside air increased air changes, more sensing and control of temperature and humidity to kind of tighter tolerances, increasing the humidity as much as you can. That way you can increase the moisture density in the air thus allow less of the viral particulates to be floating around in the air stream and having that moisture kind of capturing them and forcing them to the ground. That essentially is what ASHRAE is saying in their documentation. Now, if you go to S, go to podcasts, smart buildings academy.com for slash t 13. You scroll down to the resources, you will see the document in which I'm spending most of the time kind of providing my interpretation of the document while very good assumes a lot of knowledge

Phil Zito 5:00
And I'm going to try to fill in the gaps as we move through that. So one of the first things that I've been I've really been hammering on this for probably the better part of two years now, of just the need to audit your building systems the need to actually know what's within a building. And for those of you who are maybe struggling and I'm talking to the contractors right now and you're maybe struggling like, man, our capital projects are drying up, what can we possibly do to be keeping our guys gals busy? One of the things I would highly recommend that would actually be beneficial, I do not recommend things unless I really do think they'd be beneficial. But something that would be beneficial to your customers would be offering a remote service where your actual technicians process the customers documentation both by looking through their MEP sets and their own EMS and looking at their control system remotely and then provide a set of

Phil Zito 6:00
A Hey, this is what you have. This is what you need to upgrade in order to better monitor and control your environmental conditions your IAQ in order to provide the safest environment to your tenants. I mean, honestly, I think you could sell this like hotcakes, and it would be valuable at the same time, there are so many customers out there who are really struggling to get a grasp of what's in their building or buildings. And then what actions do they take to update the systems in those buildings? That is something that

Phil Zito 6:37
you'd be surprised how much consultants get paid to come in and do that. And why not? You mean, if you got people sitting on the bench instead of letting them go, why not you Why not going and doing that? Now from a customer's perspective. I know some of you are listening to this and you're building operators and you're like, but but Phil, what about me? Well, quite simply, you can do this as well. So how do you audit your system, we've went through this

Phil Zito 7:00
This in previous episodes, I like to think it's like Episode 207206. I'll link to it in the show notes at podcast dot smart buildings Academy comm forward slash 213. But I went through exactly how to do this. So I'm going to go through it at a high level and know that you can refer to that episode and kind of understand. Okay, so you've got to go through collect your documentation. Once you've collected your documents, you got to validate your documentation, documentation being your MEP sets, your own manuals, your submittals, etc. Once you have an idea of what you have, then you need to go and figure out what do you need to mediate in order or remediate in order to basically bring your system up to speed usually this is sensor density grabbing humidity sensors, getting control of economizers those are kind of the highlights of the things that you're going to be going and affecting in order to

Phil Zito 8:00
Make your building kind of pandemic ready, I can't even say that with a straight face. It's frickin ridiculous.

Phil Zito 8:07
But in all seriousness, that's what you need to do in order to make your system have better IAQ control, which is really what this is about, right? I don't like doing the kind of snake oil salesman, hey, pandemic, this pandemic that I just at the end of the day, we're trying to get better control of our indoor air quality. That's really what this all comes down to. Everything else is driven by that. And if you understand that, if you understand that we're trying to control indoor air quality that will be what guides your decisions. Do you need analytics to do indoor air quality? Probably not. Would it help from a reporting perspective? Yeah, but do you need it know?

Phil Zito 8:52
Another thing? Do you need to upgrade your entire building automation system? Probably not. Not really. I mean, yeah, it's great to have a single you

Phil Zito 9:00
software suite that has all this stuff built into it. But the reality is adding a couple sensors and making some programmatic changes to your field controllers, you can do most of what Asher is requiring, I mean, at the end of the day, they're requiring increased air control,

Phil Zito 9:15
increased filtration, which means you have to really up your differential pressure settings, at your home mag pickups at your

Phil Zito 9:25
air handling units to accomp account for that pressure drop across, you know, if you're using Merv 13. Now, instead of like some lower grade bag filters, you now have to go and account for that pressure job. So these are all kind of changes that you have to make. Once you've done that, once you've closed these gaps, then you implement these programmatic changes. And then you monitor the changes. So let's talk through kind of what are these changes. I feel like everyone talks about pandemic mode on LinkedIn and they talk about it but then they don't go through what it actually is. So if you're going through this document,

Phil Zito 10:00
I have listed at podcasts smart buildings Academy comm forward slash to 13. First thing you'll notice is that ASHRAE Surprise, surprise says review your current operational practices. I mean, right, we've talked through that quite a bit. You need to understand what you have, what your sequence of operations are, what your set points are, what your schedules are, those specific things are going to be very important sequence of operations are going to be important because we're going to be modifying those set points are going to be important because we're going to be modifying those and schedules are important because guess what, we're going to be modifying those as well. And the reason why we want to know all of these, because eventually Coronavirus is going to be over and we are going to roll back to more energy efficient sequences, set points and schedules because let's be real, running 100% outdoor air 24 seven fans circulation increased air changes is not energy efficient. It's not efficient on the wear and tear of your equipment. So that's the reason

Phil Zito 11:00
Reality of wanting to run a more kind of indoor air quality friendly building, you at the same time are going to have, you know, a increase in energy expenditures, you're going to have a improvements that you're gonna have to make to your equipment etc.

Phil Zito 11:21
Now there is stuff that I'm talking about in environment, monitoring around monitoring people, people counting things like that. The practicality having used people counting technologies in the past short of you know badging in and badging out and making sure that every possible access point in the building is secure short of that. badging in and badging out really being the only really truly effective way I know I'm gonna get people are gonna email me they're gonna say they're passive infrared sensors, or their analytics system can do very accurate people counting and you know what, you're probably right you They probably can

Phil Zito 12:00
Can they do it at a cost effective point that makes sense for a capital or operational budget? Probably not. But most buildings have some form of access control. And you can implement that in such a way that you can get some decent occupant counting. But at the end of the day,

Phil Zito 12:19
I personally, if I'm in your shoes, either as a contractor or as an owner, I am going to focus primarily on the IAQ increasing outdoor airflow, increasing my air change rates, increasing my temperature, increasing my humidity, getting good humidity sensing, making sure my temperature sensing is accurate. I'm gonna focus on those things along with social distancing. More than I'm going to focus on people counting my bang for my buck is on the things I just mentioned. Not really on analytics, not really on people counting I know that's gonna upset some folks that's going to probably upset a lot of manufacturers. You're going to send me emails and say, Phil

Phil Zito 12:59
Microsoft can do this, this, this and this. And I once again, want to be clear, I completely agree with you that your stuff can do that. I do not think it is necessarily the best use of capital dollars for owners who are already facing budgetary constraints due to loss of revenue. All right, I want to be clear on that.

Phil Zito 13:22
So the ASHRAE document says, you know, develop a pandemic preparedness plant plan, right, and it talks about what the plan is right, reducing the spread of infection, maintaining h HVAC systems, unsafe unhealthy conditions, minimizing impact, you know, all making people wear masks and stuff like that. It's fairly obvious stuff, screening and monitoring. So we don't need to spend a ton of time talking about that. Next up, though, it says review indoor and outdoor environment and review the space types. I think these are two things that largely get missed right?

Phil Zito 14:00
They largely get missed from the perspective of, hey, what can we do? What can we change?

Phil Zito 14:10
So, first thing they mentioned is maintained dry bulb temperatures within the comfort ranges indicated in ASHRAE 55. If you've never read ASHRAE 55 you really should be familiar with it. Regardless of whether we're in Coronavirus or whatever virus comes along later in life. You should still understand ASHRAE 55 ASHRAE 62 and ASHRAE 90 these are like things that I am shocked so many people in our industry don't understand yet they drive so much of the engineering and design of our facilities. I run into so many technicians who don't understand ASHRAE 62.1 but yet it drives minimum outdoor air damper position. It drives our co2 control of our economizer ASHRAE 55 drives setpoint selection yet people don't

Phil Zito 15:00
Understand what the thermal comfort corridor is, and they don't understand how to read a sight chart ASHRAE 90 drives a lot of equipment selection yet people don't understand what it is really going to understand those. That would be very beneficial use of your time. You know, if you're sitting there and you're not busy because you know, you don't have work or whatever, people aren't in your building, taking an hour to read these three standards, which I'll link to at podcast does smart building Academy smart things. academy.com I got mad as a mouthful, right? I'm telling you.

Phil Zito 15:35
podcasts, smart buildings Academy comm forward slash 213. I'll link to those three standards, they're very beneficial. So they break it out in cold climates and warm climates. So in cold climates, which most of us are going to be entering in the very near future. They talk about no humidification right. If the system doesn't have that you may not be able to achieve

Phil Zito 16:00
The minimum humidity. So that's something we need to start considering humidity being one of the greatest factors besides for filtration and air change rate in reducing the viral spread because of that moisture content that I talked about earlier in the episode. So we really want to go check our nortek humidifiers, make sure they're actually working, make sure that they're all set up, because we all know how we go through and we put in these humidifiers, and then we never use them because they're a pain in the butt to control and they're a pain in the butt to maintain and the downstream effects of moisture in our air systems is also pain in the butt. So we tend to turn them off. Well, it's time to turn them back on and make sure they actually work. It also talks about checking your indoor assemblies for condensation, because of this little thing called dewpoint. And as we're introducing more moisture content into our air streams, we

Phil Zito 17:00
are going to kind of raise the moisture in our air. And if we are in a cold area, we could potentially sub cool and cause condensate to build up. We've all seen it condensate building up on stuff is not good. moisture in a building is not good, we need to be aware of that. And you know, there's ways to deal with that through different control sequences. And then right making sure that we're not excessively producing humidity within our building. Now in the hot climates, the warm climates we run into the opposite. We run into if we don't have a dedicated outdoor air system or a doe as then we tend to be pulling in all this moist hot air into our outdoor air dampers to maintain that kind of hundred percent outdoor air that we're striving for. And we're introducing a bunch of moisture. So in cold climates, we have potential dewpoint issues and condensate issues and we have potential

Phil Zito 18:00
Lack of humidification issues depending on where you're at whether it's a cold moist or or a dry cold, right, whether it's a moist cold or dry cold in the hot climates, right, we have kind of the same thing whether we're dry hot, like Arizona or where a wet hot like Louisiana will drive how we are going to control things. We may be looking at deca cent wheels, we may be looking at preconditioning. With dough as units. There's a variety of systems. Obviously some of these things are going to have to be in field modifications, retrofits, things like that.

Phil Zito 18:38
What scan we have to make sure that we are maintaining moisture now talks about space types and space types. How do they affect us now, there's a lot of operational strategies around space types but from a controlling perspective, we really want to make sure that we are not driving the control of

Phil Zito 19:00
Our conference rooms or other spaces based on occupancy sensors, we really want to drive them based on 2424 seven occupancy, we want to keep air circulating in those spaces. We want to make sure that our spaces have adequate air ventilation, we want to drive towards positive pressurization as much as possible unless we're like in a hospital scenario where we need negative pressure rooms, but we want to drive positive pressurization, we want to really go and push that air out. Right, we want to make sure that we're doing that, while at the same time maintaining air changes. Now I wanted you to understand what I was just saying there, because we can have low air changes and positive pressure. How we do that is if we're exhausting less air then we're putting in we can actually be not really exhausting any air and create a positive pressure scenario.

Phil Zito 20:00
And that's not necessarily good because we're still not taking advantage of filtration. So we want to have high velocities of air, so high air changes, while also maintaining a slightly positive pressurization. Now, that being said, you could argue for negative pressurization as well, there's no real determination on positive or negative pressurization being better than the other, because you could say negative pressurization is good because it keeps all of the air constrained to that space. And so if there's a conference room full of sick people, it's not going to leak out. I will say that in most cases positive pressurization is going to be better. In a non healthcare environment and healthcare environment. Obviously, you're going to want more negative pressure situations to suck that area in and keep any infectious air in that space and not from going out.

Phil Zito 21:00
in the hallways and things like that, so we talk about space types. Next, we move to actually operating and maintaining our h fac. Now there are a bunch of documents ASHRAE has standard 180, which is basically how do you inspect to maintain commercial h fac it's talks about the common ways of maintaining that things were focused on our increased filter changes, checking of coils. And as we increase our filtering, making sure that you know, nothing's building up on those coils and that they're not being starved at the same time, making sure that our pressure drops are reasonable so that we can actually get the proper airflow through our systems so we can condition the spaces.

Phil Zito 21:47
Now when we move in to actually controlling the systems themselves, we're shifting largely from a occupancy schedule to a 24 seven schedule

Phil Zito 22:00
The main areas they ask us to focus on are going and operating all of our systems as much as we can, ideally 24 seven. So chillers.

Phil Zito 22:12
If needed boilers if needed air handling systems, vv terminal units, etc. They asked for the outdoor air ventilation to be increased as much as the H fac system can accommodate. And here's the key point, while still maintaining indoor, acceptable or acceptable indoor conditions during occupied hours. That's the real catch. You see a lot of people posting, hey, we should be doing 100% outdoor air all the time. And you know, I myself have been guilty of saying that when what I actually mean is we should run as much outdoor air as we can, while still maintaining the IAQ standards inside the buildings, specifically the ASHRAE 55 standards because at the end of the day, if we're going and we're

Phil Zito 23:00
Driving all this outdoor air in, but we're introducing all this moisture build up and we're creating mildew and damage in the space. We're not doing anyone any favors. So it's kind of this delicate dance and balance. So if you are programming this if you're developing it, you would have a IAQ. And you would be watching that IAQ, right zone temp and humidity, you'd be watching those two. And then you would be using those to drive outdoor air damper position. So it's almost like co2 driving outdoor air damper position, but it's actually zone temperature and humidity. And honestly, I will argue in most cases, humidity is going to be the more important one in a very moist climate to watch. Because with very dry climates, you can still get amazing deltas across your coil because there's no moisture in the air and you can really take advantage of

Phil Zito 24:00
Kind of evaporating, and just taking heat and reducing it and just clean transfers through the coils. I don't know why I said a evaporating, because we're not evaporating any moisture when it's actually in

Phil Zito 24:18
very dry air anywho. As I was saying, we we have that right, we're looking at zone temp and humidity to drive our outdoor air dampers. It's, it's a little unique, but it's something that works. We're also looking at a flushing sequence. This is where we're basically operating the system with maximum outdoor air flows for two hours before and after occupied times. So that's a minor change that you're going to have to make. You're going to have to be aware that this is going to require your chillers to run outside of their normal occupied hours. And then we're going to talk about they say, hey, if the building's not occupied or in the flushing mode,

Phil Zito 25:00
We can run it at minimum outdoor air since settings but we still have to be running the unit's we still have to be running so 24 seven minimum outdoor air during unoccupied hours, maximum outdoor air with it while still maintaining ASHRAE 35 standards during occupied hours, and a flush before and after occupancy. Now with va fi units, we talked about basically the exact same thing, right, run your economizer. If there's heating and cooling, to temper the air, it can provide the comfort and eliminate re circularization if it can still maintain those ASHRAE 55 standards. And so we've got to be aware of that. Also, it says hey, in areas like Arizona or wherever, where it's, you know, really dry air, we don't want to let our relative humidity be driven below 40%. So we want to prioritize right outdoor air

Phil Zito 26:00
Over humidity, what we want to do that, but at the same time, we want to make sure that we're hitting that 40 to 60% humidity range. So we want to get fresh outdoor air in. That's really important because we're flushing the air out. But we don't want to let the humidity get completely out of whack. That's really important.

Phil Zito 26:27
And another area I want to talk about here is where they talk about raising your discharge air temperature setpoint on your VA v units to around 60 degrees instead of 55. And also going and making sure that we are letting our vv terminal units try to satisfy space cooling loads through this increased temperature at which then is going to basically increase air

Phil Zito 27:00
Changes in the space, right? Because exhaust is typically going to remain constant, the supply error is going to vary. And by raising that 60 degrees discharge air, we're now introducing less cold air. So we are going to need more cold air at 60 degrees than we would need at 55. Thus, this is a easy way of increasing air changes from the terminal units. I want to make sure that makes sense right, is that if we increase discharge air to 60 degrees, then in order for that air to mix in the space and drive to let's say, 72, we're gonna need more of it because there's less capacity now in that air to absorb the heat within that space and exhaust that heat. So now we're going to have to increase our discharge airflow from those boxes, which naturally with a constant exhaust is going to increase

Phil Zito 28:00
freeze the supply, and ultimately the pressure and air changes within those spaces. So that's how all of that kind of comes together. There's a bunch more here. And I think with us running up on the 30 minute time frame, I am going to make this probably a two part episode. I'm going to start by going through kind of some sensing, I'm going to go through the control of cooling coils, heat and energy recovery. I'm going to talk through the hydronic systems. I'm going to talk through exhaust and I'm going to talk through pressure control in the next episode. So at this point in the episode, what I want you to take from here is creating a pandemic mode. The first thing we need to do is we need to know

Phil Zito 28:50
what we have in our buildings and we do that through data collection. Once we know that we can start to implement some of these sequences. What are the sequences

Phil Zito 29:00
We are primarily focused on increasing outdoor air flow, because we want fresh air while maintaining those ASHRAE 55 standards of temperature and humidity. Ideally, we want to keep humidity high more towards that 60% range, more moisture in the air that we can have while keeping people comfortable is going to basically

Phil Zito 29:26
lessen the density of the viral load within a building. So that's good for us to have moisture. So those are kind of our strategies initially that we're going to focus on in this episode we went through basic VA v changes, we talked about scheduling changes, we talked about building flushed scenarios. We talked about outdoor air and outdoor air control. And like I said in the next episode, we're going to go and look at the coils. We're going to look at pressurization. We're going to look at exhaust and we're going to talk about

Phil Zito 30:00
potential changes and sensing that we may be making. I know this was more of a kind of technical episode, so by all means, please reach out to us. Feel free to post in the discussions. And if you're watching this on YouTube post in the comments, I'd love to answer any questions for you. Thanks a ton for listening to this episode, and I look forward to talking to you in part two of this episode next week. Thanks a ton and take care

Phil Zito

Written by Phil Zito

Want to be a guest on the Podcast?

 

BE A GUEST